Can I just say how much I love cherries? They are one of my most favorite fruits. Sweet, juicy, and slightly messy. It seems like nothing is quite so good unless it stains like the Dickens. Late June and early July is cherry season in my neighborhood, but unfortunately it doesn’t last forever. We usually get a huge bumper crop and have to rush to eat, bake, or preserve our cherries before they all go bad.
I am not much of a fan of just plain canned cherries, so this year I decided to branch out and try a few different things. I feel that pie filling is always a good choice. Everybody likes pie, right? If you’ve only ever canned fruit in sugar syrup, don’t worry – pie filling is not much more complicated. It’s basically the same, except instead of sugar syrup, you add a thick sauce to the fruit. That sauce generally combines sugar, water, spices and/ or flavorings, and a thickener.
The basics of cherry pie filling
Most of the cherries found in stores are bing cherries – sweet, red, and juicy, perfect for eating fresh. These aren’t the kind that are used for making commercial cherry pie filling. Eaten plain, pie cherries are excruciatingly sour.
Funny story: my grandmother used to have a pie cherry tree in her backyard. I got a very horrible surprise when I tried to snitch a couple while she was making a pie. Those cherries were worse than lemons. Now, pie cherries are a good variety when it comes to making pies and pastries, however, because the tartness counterbalances the many cups of added sugar. As such, when making pies with bing cherries you need to add a lot of lemon juice – like 1/2 cup for seven quarts.
Before canning must come the preparation. For cherries, this means pitting. If you are canning them plain, you can get away with merely giving them a slight poke with a pin – you can spit out the pits as you eat them later. But for anything else, you really need to remove the pits first. Cherry pits are not commonly thought to be a welcome addition to pie. I happened to have inherited this lovely cast-iron number from my grandmother, who I believe purchased it in the 1950s. If you aren’t fortunate enough to have a grandma as awesome as mine, there are many to choose from on Amazon, made of easy-to-clean plastic.
I used a recipe that came with some Thick Gel modified starch, that is especially for making pie filling. Instead of becoming runny after baking, it will remain thick. It comes in powdered form. Most pie recipes call for some kind of thickener, whether it’s flour, corn starch or something else. If you don’t have Thick Gel immediately on hand, you can substitute regular corn starch. I prefer not to use flour because I feel it gives the pie a pasty, floury flavor.
This recipe makes seven quarts of cherry pie filling, so I hope you really like cherry pie or know someone who does.
Cherry Pie Filling Ingredients
6 quarts cherries, washed and pitted
7 cups granulated sugar
1 3/4 cups Thick Gel (or similar)
9 1/3 cups cold water
1/2 c lemon juice (more if your cherries are extra-sweet)
1 tsp cinnamon (optional)
2 tsp almond extract (optional)
1/2 tsp red food coloring (optional)
Combine all ingredients in a large pot except cherries, lemon juice, and almond extract. Stir over medium high heat until mixture comes to a boil. Add lemon juice and boil for an additional minute.
If using corn starch or flour: divide cherries evenly in seven quart jars. Stir in almond extract just before ladling mixture into jars.
If using Thick Gel or similar: The mixture will be too thick to spread down into the bottom of the jars, filling up the spaces between the cherries. Instead, remove the mixture from heat, stir in almond extract, and fold in cherries. You may need a large cooking spoon instead of a ladle to fill your seven quart jars.
Be sure to wipe the rims of your jars very thoroughly before applying the lids – pie filling is messy, and residue on the rim will prevent the lid from creating a proper seal. Process your jars for 30-35 minutes (depending on your altitude) in a boiling-water canner.
One quart of pie filling equals one pie. Use as you would a can of pie filling from the store.
Want to learn more about canning?
- All-American Pressure Canner (Ultra heavy duty, more expensive)
- DVD: At Home Canning for Beginners and Beyond
- Ball Blue Book Guide to Preserving
- Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving
- Ball Canning Utensil Set
- Presto Pressure Canner (budget-friendly)
- Simply Canning by Sharon Peterson
- Zaycon for purchases of large quantities of meat, chicken, bacon, and other foods. (affiliate link)
- …and, search this site for “canning”.
Always be up to date with new articles and giveaways!
Latest posts by Beth Buck (see all)
- Need More Mistletoe Time? Try These Food Storage Holiday Recipes - November 17, 2017
- How to Can Peaches and Nectarines - July 24, 2017
- 8 Truths About Frugality That Everyone, Not Just Preppers, Should Know - April 25, 2017
- Survival Mom DIY: Bone Broth For Nourishment During Hard Times - March 30, 2017
- Why Nutrition is an Essential Part of Preparedness - November 18, 2016